Competition Appeal Court - 2024

4 judgments
  • Filters
  • Judges
  • Labels
  • Alphabet
Sort by:
4 judgments
Citation
Judgment date
October 2024
The Competition Appeal Court may not, under section 173 or otherwise, transfer a Tribunal-commenced statutory review to itself.
Competition law – jurisdiction and procedure – whether the Competition Appeal Court may transfer a review initiated in the Competition Tribunal to itself; scope of section 173 inherent judicial powers; distinction between statutory reviews under section 27(1)(c) and PAJA/legality reviews; effect of Group Five decision on forum competence.
7 October 2024
April 2024
Reported
Whether coordinated JV bids by a majority partner amounted to per se price‑fixing or collusive tendering — appeal dismissed.
Competition Act s 4(1)(b) – horizontal versus vertical relationships; definition and status of joint ventures/partnerships as 'firms'; characterization of per se prohibitions (price‑fixing and collusive tendering) under ANSAC; counterfactual analysis for horizontality; hub‑and‑spoke and intra‑enterprise conspiracy doctrines; role of disclosure, deception and demonstrable harm in distinguishing naked cartels from ancillary coordination in JV bidding contexts.
26 April 2024
March 2024
Concurrent jurisdiction prevails: a NERSA maximum gas price does not preclude Competition Commission investigations into excessive pricing.
Competition law — concurrent jurisdiction — s 3(1A) Competition Act — sector regulator’s price determination under s 21(1)(p) Gas Act does not oust Commission’s jurisdiction — abuse of dominance (s 8(1)(a)) investigations valid despite NERSA maximum price — memorandum of agreement confirms cooperation.
5 March 2024
January 2024
Reported
Commission’s SOC referral failed to plead jurisdictional and connecting facts for many foreign and non‑trading respondents.
Competition law – alleged cartel in USD/ZAR market – single overarching conspiracy (SOC) pleading requirements – need to plead common anti‑competitive objective, intentional contribution and knowledge/foreseeability – distinction between subject‑matter and personal jurisdiction for peregrini – limits on joinder of holding companies and on adding parties after referral – appealability of jurisdictional rulings in interests of justice.
8 January 2024